What to Bring to an Interview: A Checklist for Candidates

Michelle M
2 days ago
10 min read

For candidates, an interview is not simply a discussion of credentials. It is a practical assessment of leadership readiness and executive judgment. For professionals pursuing Director, Vice President, or C-suite roles, generic interview guidance such as bringing multiple copies of a résumé offers little value. That advice is designed for early-career candidates, not for leaders expected to operate at enterprise scale.

When entering a boardroom to meet with a CEO, board member, or private equity sponsor, candidates are evaluated on how they think, structure decisions, and present themselves as future leaders of the organization. The interview functions as a live simulation of executive performance, not a retrospective review of past roles.

What a candidate brings into that room matters. The materials presented during an executive interview act as tangible evidence of strategic discipline, organizational rigor, and operational preparedness. This checklist-focused guide outlines what senior candidates should bring to an interview to move beyond basic preparedness and position themselves as credible, consultative leaders from the first interaction.

What to Bring to an Interview: A Checklist for Candidates

This guide provides a comprehensive "Executive Arsenal" checklist. We will move beyond the basics to explore the high-value strategic assets you must bring to an interview to shift the dynamic from "candidate" to "consultative partner."

The Psychology of "The Prop"

Before dissecting the specific items, it is critical to understand the psychological impact of bringing the right materials. In a typical interview, the dynamic is asymmetrical: the interviewer has the power (the job), and the candidate has the need (the offer).

By bringing tangible, high-quality strategic documents, you disrupt this asymmetry. You are no longer asking for a job; you are presenting a business case. When you slide a bound "Competitive Analysis Dossier" across the table, you trigger a "Reciprocity Bias." You have done work for them for free. You have demonstrated that you are already thinking like an owner.

The "Clean Table" Rule:

Strategic artifacts also serve a tactical purpose: they clear the table. Executives are distracted. They have phones buzzing and Slack notifications firing. By placing a physical document in front of them, you force their visual attention away from their screens and onto your narrative. You control the focal point of the room.

1. The 30-60-90 Day Strategic Plan

The Ultimate Differentiator

If you bring only one "extra" item, let it be this. The 30-60-90 Day Plan is the single most effective tool for closing an executive role. It transforms the interview from a retrospective ("Tell me what you did at your last job") to a prospective ("Let’s discuss what I will do for your company").

The Format:

Do not keep this in your head. Print it. Use high-quality, heavy-stock paper. Place it in a slim, branded folder.

The Content:

Days 1-30 (The Learning Phase): Detail exactly how you will audit the current state. "I will interview the top 10 clients," "I will audit the CRM data hygiene," "I will shadow the sales engineering team." This shows humility and diligence.
Days 31-60 (The Assessment Phase): Detail the "Quick Wins." Identify low-hanging fruit you expect to target based on your outside-in view. "I will streamline the approval workflow for discounts," "I will consolidate the three redundant software licenses."
Days 61-90 (The Transformation Phase): Detail the strategic pivot. "I will present the FY25 go-to-market strategy," "I will launch the pilot for the new vertical."

The "Draft" Disclaimer:

Crucially, watermark the document as "DRAFT / HYPOTHESIS." This shows deference. You are saying, "I have done my homework, but I know I don't have all the internal data yet. I want to build the final version with you."

2. The Competitive Intelligence Dossier

Showing, Not Just Telling

Most candidates say, "I research the company." The top 1% of candidates prove it.

Create a 3-5 page briefing document titled "Market Landscape & Competitive Opportunities." This document should not just list competitors; it should analyze them.

What to Include:

The "Outside-In" Audit: A critique of their current customer journey. "I signed up for your demo and your competitor's demo. Here is a table comparing the speed-to-lead."
The White Space Map: A visualization of where the market is going vs. where the company is positioned. "Competitors A and B are fighting for the enterprise. No one is serving the mid-market with a self-serve motion. Here is the revenue opportunity."
Social Sentiment Analysis: "I scraped G2 Crowd and Reddit. Your customers love the product but hate the billing transparency. Here is a one-page plan to fix billing transparency."

The Effect:

This document creates a "consultative workshop" atmosphere. The interviewer will inevitably pick it up and say, "Wait, you actually went through our checkout flow?" Now you are debating strategy, not answering "What is your greatest weakness?"

3. The "Brag Book" (The Portfolio of Evidence)

Quantifying the Unverifiable

Resumes are claims. Portfolios are proof. In creative fields (Design, Marketing), portfolios are standard. In Operations, Finance, and Sales, they are rare—and therefore powerful.

What to Include for Non-Creative Roles:

For Sales Leaders: An anonymized "Deal Anatomy." A one-pager showing a complex, multi-year deal you closed. Map the stakeholders, the obstacles, and the final contract value.
For Finance Leaders: A sanitized "Dashboard Before & After." Show a messy, unintelligible Excel sheet (Before) and the clean, automated Tableau dashboard you built (After).
For Operations Leaders: A "Process Map." A diagram showing a broken supply chain workflow you inherited and the streamlined workflow you implemented, with the "Time Saved" metric highlighted in bold.

Privacy Note:

Redact everything. Aggressively. Black out client names, specific dollar figures, and proprietary data from previous employers. The interviewer needs to see the structure of your success, not the secrets of your former boss. In fact, seeing heavily redacted documents increases your trust score—it proves you are discreet.

4. The "Prepared Questions" Menu

The Interviewer's Ledger

At the end of the interview, when they ask, "Do you have any questions for us?", do not fumble for a notebook or ask generic questions like "What is the culture like?"

Bring a printed list of 10-15 deep, strategic questions.

Why Printed?

It signals preparation. When you open your leather folio and reveal a typed list of questions, it shows you treat this meeting as a board meeting.

The "High-Altitude" Questions:

"I read in the 10-K that you are expanding into APAC. How does the current supply chain infrastructure support that, given the geopolitical tension in the region?"
"If we look back 12 months from now, what is the one 'failure mode' that would have prevented this role from being successful?"
"How does the private equity sponsor view the exit horizon? Are we optimizing for EBITDA growth or top-line velocity in the next 24 months?"

5. The Physical Kit: Professionalism in the Details

The intellectual assets are critical, but the physical delivery mechanism matters. "Smart Casual" or "Business Formal" applies to your accessories as much as your suit.

The Portfolio / Padfolio

Ditch the free notebook you got at a conference 5 years ago with a vendor logo on it. Invest in a high-quality leather or vegan leather padfolio. It should hold:

A legal pad (yellow or white).
A slot for loose documents (your resume copies).
A slot for business cards.

The Pen

Bring two. One to use, and one for when the first one runs out of ink. Do not bring a chewed-up Bic. Use a metal-bodied pen (like a Parker Jotter or similar). It sounds trivial, but in a negotiation, every subconscious signal of "quality" counts.

The Resume (The Right Way)

Bring 5-7 copies. Even if you are meeting one person.

Why? You might get "surprise" interviewers added to the loop. If the CEO pops their head in, handing them a crisp resume immediately orients them.
The Paper: Print it on 32lb linen or cotton bond paper. The tactile difference between standard printer paper and resume paper is noticeable. It adds a "weight" to your candidacy.

6. The Tech Strategy: Tablet vs. Notebook

In 2024/2025, is it acceptable to bring an iPad or laptop to an interview?

The Verdict: Use with Extreme Caution.

The Risk: Screens create a barrier. If you are looking at a screen, you are not looking at the interviewer. Notifications (even silent ones) break eye contact.
The Exception: If you are presenting a digital portfolio or a live dashboard demo. In this case, bring a tablet (iPad Pro) rather than a laptop. A tablet can be laid flat on the table, allowing both you and the interviewer to look at it together (collaborative), whereas a laptop screen acts as a wall (defensive).

Recommendation:

Stick to pen and paper for note-taking. It proves you are listening. Typing indicates you are transcribing (or checking email). Writing indicates you are synthesizing.

7. The Emergency Kit (The "Boy Scout" Rule)

Murphy's Law applies to interviews. A small "Go Bag" kept in your car or briefcase can save the day.

Breath Mints: Not gum. Never gum.
Tide Pen: For the inevitable coffee spill 10 minutes before the meeting.
Water Bottle: Do not rely on them offering water. Dry mouth kills interview performance.
Printed Directions and Contact Info: If your phone dies or you lose signal in the elevator, do you know who to ask for at the front desk?

8. What NOT to Bring

Equally important is knowing what to leave in the car.

Competitor Products: If you are interviewing at Pepsi, do not walk in holding a Starbucks cup (unless you know they serve Starbucks). Ideally, bring no branded coffee cups. It looks too casual.
Luggage: If you flew in for the interview, leave your suitcase at the hotel or front desk. Dragging a roller bag into the CEO’s office signals "I am transient," not "I am here to stay."
The "Entourage": Never bring a spouse, parent, or friend to the lobby. It screams immaturity.

Case Scenario: The VP of Operations Interview

Let's look at how this comes together in a real-world scenario.

Candidate: Sarah, applying for VP of Operations at a Logistics Firm.

The "Bring" List:

Leather Padfolio containing 5 copies of her resume on ivory paper.
The "90-Day Operational Roadmap" (Printed): A detailed plan on how she will optimize the warehouse throughput before the Q4 peak season.
The "Network Analysis" (Printed): A map she created showing the inefficiency in their current last-mile delivery partners based on public data.
Reference Sheet: A pre-printed list of 3 references (former CEO, former Peer, former Direct Report) with their cell phone numbers and a brief sentence on what they can vouch for (e.g., "Jane can speak to my ability to cut costs by 15%").

The Result:

Ten minutes into the interview, the interviewer asks, "How would you handle the

upcoming holiday rush?"

Sarah does not just answer. She opens her folio, pulls out the 90-Day Roadmap, slides it across the table, and says, "I actually modeled out that exact scenario. If you look at 'Month 2' on this plan, here is how I would reallocate the shift labor..."

The interview is over. She has the job. She did not just talk about the job; she brought the job with her.

Here is a high-level, executive-focused FAQ section aligned to your blog’s positioning, tone, and enterprise audience. It is written for Google Docs/Word use, avoids entry-level framing, and reinforces the “executive arsenal” concept.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why does an executive interview require a different level of preparation?

At Director, VP, and C-Suite level, interviews are evaluations of leadership readiness, not competency checks. Interviewers assess how candidates think, structure problems, communicate under pressure, and represent the organization externally. Preparation must therefore demonstrate strategic judgment, operational discipline, and executive presence, not just experience.

What is meant by “artifacts” in an executive interview?

Artifacts are physical or digital materials that support executive-level discussion. These may include strategy summaries, operating models, dashboards, transformation roadmaps, or board-style slide packs. They act as evidence of how a candidate thinks, leads, and delivers at enterprise scale.

Is bringing materials to an interview seen as presumptuous?

When done correctly, no. At executive level, bringing structured materials signals preparedness, confidence, and respect for the decision-making process. The key is relevance and restraint. Materials should support discussion, not dominate it, and should always align to the organization’s context and challenges.

How many materials should an executive bring to an interview?

Quality matters more than quantity. Most executive interviews require a small, curated set of assets that demonstrate strategic thinking, delivery capability, and leadership judgment. Overloading the table with documents can dilute impact and suggest a lack of prioritization.

What types of documents are most valuable at executive level?

High-value materials typically include strategic frameworks, operating model diagrams, transformation case summaries, performance dashboards, and risk or governance perspectives. These demonstrate how a candidate would operate in role, not how they operated in the past.

Should materials be tailored for each interview?

Yes. Executive interviews are context-specific. Materials should be tailored to the organization’s industry, maturity, ownership model, and current strategic priorities. Generic documents signal generic thinking, which is a red flag at senior level.

How do interviewers typically react to executive-level preparation?

Senior interviewers often respond positively when preparation elevates the conversation. Strong materials can shift the dynamic from question-and-answer to peer-level discussion, allowing interviewers to visualize the candidate as a future leader rather than an applicant.

Can these materials replace verbal storytelling?

No. Artifacts complement executive storytelling, they do not replace it. Leaders are expected to communicate clearly, concisely, and persuasively without relying on documents. Materials should act as anchors for discussion, not crutches.

Is this level of preparation expected for all senior roles?

The higher the role and the closer the interviewer is to the board or investors, the more this level of preparation is expected. Private equity-backed firms, regulated industries, and transformation-heavy environments particularly value structured, evidence-based thinking.

What risk does a candidate take by not preparing at this level?

Without executive-level preparation, candidates risk being perceived as operationally narrow, strategically shallow, or unready for enterprise leadership. In competitive senior hiring markets, lack of visible rigor can be the deciding factor between otherwise equally qualified candidates.

If you want, I can also:

Create a one-page executive interview checklist formatted as a printable asset
Add a case study showing how preparation shifted an interview outcome
Build a table mapping interview artifacts to leadership signals

Tell me what you want next.

Conclusion: Preparation is Persuasion

In the final analysis, the items you bring to an interview are a reflection of how you value the opportunity. Bringing nothing signals that you view the interview as a casual chat. Bringing a "Strategic Arsenal" signals that you view the interview as the first business meeting of your tenure.

For the enterprise leader, the cost of printing a bound dossier or a 90-day plan is negligible ($20 at FedEx Office). The return on investment is a career-defining offer. Pack your bag not just with paper, but with proof.

Hashtags:

#ExecutiveInterview #CareerStrategy #Leadership #InterviewTips #CSuite