What Is A Constructive Change Order?
- Michelle M
- May 5
- 6 min read
In construction change is inevitable. No matter how carefully planned a project is,unplanned conditions, design errors, or evolving client requirements can shift the project’s scope and timeline. While formal change orders are well understood, there is a more subtle, and sometimes contentious, type of change order known as the constructive change order.
Understanding constructive change orders is key, especially when managing some of the most expensive construction projects in the world. These massive undertakings, spanning billions of dollars and involving thousands of stakeholders, cannot afford misunderstandings about scope, responsibility, and compensation. This is where a solid grasp of constructive change orders comes into play.
This blog explores what constructive change orders are, how they impact projects, and why mastering this concept can save time, money, and legal issues.
What Is a Constructive Change Order?
A constructive change order occurs when an owner (or their representative) effectively alters the contract terms or scope of work without issuing a formal written change order. These changes are typically the result of actions, directions, or circumstances that force the contractor to deviate from the original plan.
The term “constructive” is key. It means that, although no official change order was issued, the nature of the work was changed in practice, and the contractor should be entitled to additional compensation or time.
Common examples include:
The owner issues directives that conflict with the original design
The project team encounters site conditions differing from those specified
Excessive inspections or rework demands cause schedule disruptions
Delays in approvals or access hinder work progression
Ambiguous specifications require the contractor to perform extra work
In each of these cases, the contractor is put in a position where they must perform differently than initially agreed, without formal acknowledgment. That’s where claims for constructive change orders arise.
Why Constructive Change Orders Matter in Large-Scale Projects
In smaller projects, such disputes might be minor. But on the most expensive construction projects, the stakes are astronomically high. Consider infrastructure megaprojects like airports, subways, nuclear plants, and offshore oil rigs, where even small changes can escalate into millions in added costs and months of delay.
For example:
The Big Dig in Boston, one of the most expensive construction projects in U.S. history, faced countless claims rooted in design discrepancies and unforeseen conditions, many classified as constructive changes.
The Berlin Brandenburg Airport experienced years of delay partly due to conflicting directives and rework orders, classic constructive changes that ballooned costs.
In such cases, understanding, documenting, and managing constructive change orders can mean the difference between profit and financial disaster.
The Legal Framework Around Constructive Change Orders
Contract law recognizes that constructive changes occur when an owner’s actions (or inactions) effectively alter the scope of work, even without formal documentation. To succeed in a constructive change order claim, contractors generally need to prove:
Directive or Condition: An action or instruction (explicit or implied) by the owner that altered the work.
Deviation: The contractor performed work beyond or different from the contract terms.
Entitlement: The contractor is entitled to an equitable adjustment in price and or time.
Timely Notification: The contractor notified the owner of the change and its impact.
Failure to meet these requirements can result in denied claims, leading to disputes, arbitration, or litigation.
Constructive Change Order Triggers
Let’s break down some real-world scenarios where constructive change orders typically arise:
Defective Specifications
If the contract’s design or technical specs are flawed, and the contractor has to provide extra work or materials to meet project requirements, a constructive change has occurred.
Differing Site Conditions
Unexpected ground conditions (e.g., rock instead of soil) that were not disclosed in the bid documents can qualify as constructive changes, warranting compensation.
Over-Inspection or Micromanagement
Owners who impose excessive quality control measures or require repeated rework beyond contract terms effectively create a constructive change.
Delays in Owner Responsibilities
Late approvals, slow responses to RFIs (Requests for Information), or failure to provide access on time can disrupt the schedule and trigger constructive change claims.
Ambiguous or Conflicting Instructions
If the project owner issues conflicting directions during construction, forcing contractors to perform work outside original specifications, this is grounds for a constructive change order.
How to Manage Constructive Change Orders Effectively
On most expensive construction projects, managing constructive changes proactively is essential. Here are best practices for success:
Early Identification
Train project teams to recognize potential constructive changes early before they escalate into major claims.
Document Everything
Keep detailed records of communications, directives, meeting minutes, inspection reports, and field conditions. Proper documentation is the backbone of successful claims.
Timely Notifications
Submit written notices to the owner as soon as a change is identified. Most contracts have strict timelines for notice.
Cost and Schedule Impact Analysis
Quantify the financial and time impacts of the change. Provide supporting data such as labor logs, equipment usage, and delay analyses.
Negotiate Proactively
Engage in dialogue with the owner before the situation becomes adversarial. Early negotiation can lead to formalizing the change and reaching equitable adjustments.
The Role of Project Managers and Legal Teams
Project managers on large projects must be vigilant guardians against unapproved scope creep. They need to walk a fine line, cooperating with the owner’s evolving needs while protecting their firm’s commercial interests.
Legal teams play a critical role too. By reviewing directives and correspondence, they can advise on whether a constructive change claim is valid and how to structure it for maximum success.
Constructive Change Orders in the Context of Megaprojects
When managing the most expensive construction projects, constructive changes can arise from a variety of sources:
Shifts in political priorities (e.g., environmental regulations)
Currency fluctuations affecting imported materials
Coordination breakdowns among international joint ventures
Evolving security requirements (common in airports and defense projects)
These factors amplify the need for robust constructive change order management processes. The bigger the project, the more complex and frequent such changes become.
How Technology Is Changing Constructive Change Order Management
Modern construction technology is helping project teams manage constructive change orders more effectively:
Project Management Software: Platforms like Procore, Aconex, and Autodesk Build allow real-time tracking of changes and RFIs.
Document Control Systems: Ensure that every directive, submittal, and approval is properly logged and retrievable.
AI-Powered Analytics: Tools that detect patterns in directives and identify early signs of scope creep.
Mobile Apps: Enable field teams to document site conditions with photos, geotags, and timestamps for evidence.
By leveraging these tools, contractors can strengthen their constructive change order claims and reduce disputes.
Consequences of Poor Constructive Change Management
Failure to manage constructive change orders properly can lead to severe consequences:
Cost Overruns: Uncompensated extra work erodes profit margins.
Schedule Delays: Scope changes without time adjustments cause critical path slippage.
Disputes and Litigation: Disagreements over changes escalate into formal claims, costing time and legal fees.
Damaged Relationships: Protracted conflicts strain the relationship between owners and contractors, jeopardizing future collaboration.
Reputational Harm: Poor handling of changes on high-profile projects can tarnish a company’s industry standing.
Constructive Change Orders: Friend or Foe?
While often viewed negatively, constructive change orders aren’t inherently bad. In fact, they are a natural part of dynamic, large-scale projects. What makes the difference is how they are managed.
When handled proactively, constructive change orders:
Ensure fair compensation for extra work
Keep the project aligned with evolving needs
Provide a structured way to handle inevitable changes
Strengthen owner-contractor relationships through transparency
On the flip side, unmanaged constructive changes can spiral into financial losses and legal battles.
Final Thoughts: Mastering Constructive Change Orders for Project Success
In the world of construction, especially on the most expensive construction projects, change is the only constant. Whether driven by design evolution, field conditions, or shifting owner priorities, changes will occur.
The constructive change order represents both a challenge and an opportunity. Contractors who master the art of identifying, documenting, and negotiating constructive changes will not only protect their margins but also build a reputation for professionalism and reliability.
The key is to foster a culture of vigilance, documentation, and open communication. By treating every potential change as an opportunity to clarify scope and align expectations, project teams can navigate even the most complex projects with confidence.
Constructive change orders are not just legal claims. They are the engine that keeps projects adaptive and responsive in the face of real-world challenges. Whether you’re building a local office complex or managing a multibillion-dollar infrastructure icon, mastering constructive change orders is essential to delivering projects that succeed in every sense.
Subscribe and share your thoughts and experiences in the comments!
Professional Project Manager Templates are available here
Hashtags
